2002N-0273 Animal Proteins Prohibited in Ruminant Feed
FDA Comment Number : EC125
Submitter : Ms. Marliese Bonk Date & Time: 12/09/2005 02:12:55
Organization : Ms. Marliese Bonk
Category : Individual Consumer
Issue Areas/Comments
In early 2004, following the discovery of mad cow disease in a Washington state downed dairy cow, the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) took emergency action to ban the slaughter of non-ambulatory cattle for human consumption.

In July 2004 the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) followed the lead of the USDA and prohibited the use of all materials from downed cattle in FDA-regulated human food, including dietary supplements and cosmetics. Also in July 2004, the FDA announced its tentative conclusion to ban all materials from downed cattle in animal feed.

It is my understanding that the FDA, now, has caved in to pressure from the meat industry and reversed its earlier position on non-ambulatory animals recently announcing that it plans to allow the carcasses of downed and dead animals to be rendered for animal feed as long as the brain and spinal cord have been removed. This would permit downed cattle to be killed for use in feed for birds (chickens & turkeys), pigs and companion animals. (Materials from downed cattle have been prohibited in feed for ruminants -- cattle, sheep and goats -- since 1997.)

Allowing sick, non-ambulatory cattle to be killed for animal feed will result in unnecessary pain and suffering. Downed animals should be humanely euthanized immediately, not kept alive and/or transported to be killed for rendering.

Therefore, please be advised that I, as a consumer, strongly oppose the use of non-ambulatory cattle in animal feed for reasons of health, ethics and humaneness!


Marliese Bonk