Docket Management
Docket: 98N-0359 - Program Priorities in the Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition
Comment Number: EC -3

Accepted - Volume 6

Comment Record
Commentor Mrs. Pamela A. Chumley Date/Time 2001-09-14 12:14:06
Organization International Jelly & Preserve Association
Category Association

Comments for FDA General
1. General Comments September 14, 2001 Dockets Management Branch (HFA-305) Food and Drug Administration 5630 Fishers Lane, Room 1061 Rockville, Maryland 20857 RE: Docket No. 98N-0359; Program Priorities in the Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition The International Jelly and Preserve Association (IJPA) appreciates the opportunity to provide input regarding FDA's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition's (CFSAN) program priorities for the year 2002, as requested in the July 18 Federal Register (FR) notice (66 FR 37480). IJPA is a national trade association representing the manufacturers of jellies, jams, preserves and nonstandardized fruit spreads, and the suppliers of goods and services to the industry, including ingredient suppliers of fruit, sweeteners and pectin. A list of manufacturer members is enclosed. We applaud the Agency for continuing to provide interested parties the opportunity to participate in the CFSAN priority-setting process. IJPA previously submitted comments on CFSAN’s priorities for 1999, 2000 and 2001 in response to earlier Agency requests. (See IJPA’s July 13, 1998 and September 23, 1999 and August 23, 2000 comments to the docket.) We continue to agree that one of the Center’s greatest priorities remains the Food Safety Initiative (FSI), including the emphasis on imported products in addition to domestic products. As part of FSI, coordination on foodborne disease outbreaks should be a priority. Too often a food is wrongly implicated in a foodborne disease outbreak because of the lack of coordination among state and federal agencies investigating the outbreak. Produce safety also continues to be important. The prevention of microbial contamination at the grower and packer levels will decrease the incidences of foodborne illnesses associated with fresh produce. However, as our earlier comments stated, there are other important, on-going functions on which the Agency should focus its efforts, namely the continued maintenance and administration of the food standards program, national uniformity, promoting international harmonization, preventing economic fraud and enforcing product labeling. We still strongly believe these areas deserve CFSAN’s attention and a place on the “A” list of priorities. It is evident from comments received on the Agency’s Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (ANPRM) on food standards (60 FR 67492; December 29, 1995) that a number of existing standards presently serve as barriers to the utilization of new technologies and required ingredients to improve existing products. As a result, petitions have been prepared and filed in several important product categories to affect needed amendments to recognize the advances in food technology and the need for flexibility. IJPA submitted detailed comments on the ANPRM, pointing out the general benefits of maintaining core food standards and the beneficial interplay between those standards and the general standard adopted by FDA under the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act, 21 CFR 130.10. On March 31, 1997, the Association also submitted a Citizen Petition that reflected the consensus reached within the fruit spread industry on how FDA should proceed in implementing the ANPRM with respect to the standards of identity of interest to this industry. The petition requested that the standards for artificially sweetened jellies and jams be repealed because these standards were obsolete and unnecessary. IJPA’s efforts to repeal obsolete standards should be supported by FDA, but almost five years later, no action has been taken by the Agency, despite the fact that the Association offered a solution to streamline the standards for these products. The goal of the ANPRM is important. Standards need to be updated and modernized in keeping with improving technology, as the Agency itself acknowledged in the document, “2000 CFSAN Program Priorities.” Item 2 on the “B” list for Strategy 2.2 – Nutrition, Health Claims and Labeling is to “develop a coordinated plan between FDA and USDA to correlate existing food standards with current technological innovations.” While not included in the 2001 priorities, we believe this is an important goal and should be included in the 2002 priorities. Industry should be allowed to participate in any current discussions regarding the development of such a plan to assist in the process. Similarly, national uniformity among federal and state agencies should be an “A” list priority for CFSAN in FY 2002. There should be a single set of food safety regulations interpreted in the same way by both federal and state regulators. A uniform set of regulations and interpretations will eliminate the confusion that currently exists as industry strives for compliance at the local and federal levels. The modernization and maintenance of United States (U.S.) food standards and national uniformity of regulations are also important as the U.S. participates in the Codex Alimentarius process. In order for the U.S. to be an effective player within Codex, U.S. standards must be science-based, reflective of current practices and be national in scope, which will give the U.S. a strong basis for negotiation. It is, therefore, critical that the U.S. positions on several Codex standards be thoroughly reviewed by industry to assure that current industry practices are reflected. We, therefore, encourage more timely communications between FDA and industry. In the increasingly global marketplace, the promotion of international harmonization is imperative, and the U.S. should take a leadership role in the Codex process. It is crucial that U.S. positions be shared with other countries in a timely manner so meaningful discussions can occur during Codex committee meetings. Economic fraud also should be a CFSAN priority because of its importance to both consumers and industry. FDA must continue to pursue and prosecute fraudulent activities. Individuals and companies engaged in such activities are just as likely to have little regard for the welfare and safety of the public and should not be allowed to operate. FDA's efforts in this regard should be to enforce the existing statutory provisions. Related to economic fraud is the accurate labeling of products. IJPA has alerted the Agency to several instances of economic fraud with respect to the inaccurate labeling of jams and jellies. The standards of identity for these products requires that the total soluble solids content of finished fruit preserves, jams and jellies be not less than 65%. However, there are products available on the market that have considerably lower total soluble solids content, but they are labeled as jams and jellies. This constitutes economic fraud because such products contain more moisture (water) and less fruit and/or sweeteners, which are expensive ingredients in the production of jams and jellies. The manufacturers of these products have a significant economic advantage over compliant products on the market. It is, therefore, important for FDA to enforce the accurate labeling of products. In conclusion, IJPA appreciates the opportunity to provide comments on CFSAN’s 2002 priorities. While we agree that the Food Safety Initiative should remain one of CFSAN's top priorities, the Agency is also responsible for other important functions as outlined in these comments. Thus, we encourage the Agency to balance its resources accordingly. Sincerely, Pamela A. Chumley President PAC/jcm ACTIVE MEMBERS International Jelly & Preserve Association American Spoon Foods Clements Foods Company T.W. Garner Food Company M.A. Gedney Company House of Webster, Inc. Smucker Specialty Foods, Inc. Knott's Berry Farm Foods The Kroger Company The Red Wing Company, Inc. Red Wing - California Safeway The J.M. Smucker Company Torbitt & Castleman Trappist Preserves Welch's The Whipple Company

EC -3