U.S. Food and Drug Administration
FDA Consumer magazine
July-August 2001
Table of Contents
By Carol Lewis
In this age of increased health awareness, people are willing to pay a premium for wholesome products. So when a food company touted its high-priced healthy treats as being nearly fat free and containing almost no calories, vendors all over the United States began buying them by the baker's dozens. But when suspicious customers helped prove that the treats contained more calories than they bargained for, more than just the company's cookies crumbled--its sole officer was arrested and charged with committing multiple crimes.
Vernon L. Patterson, president of Genesis II Foods Inc. of Chicago, pleaded guilty in federal court on Sept.14, 2000, to misbranding food products, mail fraud, and unlawful monetary transactions. The Food and Drug Administration's Chicago district office referred the food misbranding case to its Office of Criminal Investigations because Patterson previously had ignored the agency's misbranded food warnings, making his negligence a criminal offense. Judge Ruben Castillo of the Northern District of Illinois sentenced Patterson, 43, to a year in jail, three years supervised release, and $3,925 in fines.
The case began with a number of complaints to the FDA dating back to 1993. Consumers and health-care professionals nationwide were concerned about a line of products called "Skinny" treats. They were challenging the products' labeling claims.
Myrna Sears, a Baltimore distributor for some of Genesis II's products, told FDA investigators in an affidavit that after Patterson contacted her about purchasing his low-fat snacks, she bought rolls, carob-iced doughnuts, and white-iced apple doughnuts. All of the items claimed on their labels to contain 1 to 2 grams of fat and between 125 and 165 calories. But one of Sears' customers became suspicious about the good taste of the treats and sent samples to a lab to have their nutritional content verified. The samples tested for substantially higher fat and calorie contents than were being declared on the labels. The carob doughnut alone contained 23.5 grams of fat and 411 calories.
Sears contacted Genesis II and requested a company nutritional lab analysis so that she could compare it with the one done independently. What she didn't buy from Patterson were his rapid-fire excuses when the company's analysis confirmed her customer's suspicions.
At first, Patterson told Sears that what was on the package was correct. In fact, he said that he would not have been allowed to label them otherwise. When she revealed the results of her customer's analysis, he told her, "Just don't sell to that customer anymore." In the next breath, Patterson told Sears, after she threatened to notify the FDA, that the agency was only interested in pharmaceuticals and would not do anything about foods. When she didn't back down, Patterson became angry and verbally abusive. He concluded the conversation by saying that he didn't need her business anyway.
This was not the first time that the FDA had come up against Patterson. The agency had shut down his previous place of employment, where he was a salesman of health foods, for promoting a 21-calorie cookie that actually contained 400 calories. And Sears recalled another earlier incident when Patterson sold her a healthy "Eggless Doughnut" that he claimed contained the same amount of calories as a regular doughnut. He told her, however, that only 25 of those calories were actually absorbed by the body, because the company used "predigested fiber."
Besides the economic fraud of Patterson's actions, there was a health issue. People with high cholesterol, liver disease, and heart problems are at risk from eating certain foods, and need to closely monitor their fat, calorie and sugar intakes for medical reasons. One woman in Georgia feared for the health of her husband, who liked the "skinny" products, but who also had diabetes. Another woman in Mississippi piled on the pounds during the six months that she ate $500 worth of allegedly skinny products. Similar complaints continued to filter in from all over the country, and many were accompanied by product samples.
The case began to unravel when an FDA administrative investigation of Genesis II in April 1994 met with much resistance. The agency's consumer safety officer (CSO) was initially refused entry by confrontational employees, and the Chicago Police Department was called in. Patterson, meanwhile, was vacationing on a Caribbean island, but was reached by telephone. He said that he knew he had problems with his product labeling, and that he intended to correct them. At the same time, he blamed his Chicago-based manufacturer, Cloverhill Pastry-Vend Inc. for spraying soy oil in the baking ovens. He claimed this created a fat build-up in the product, which explained the labeling discrepancies.
But during the inspection, no Genesis II products were provided, despite the CSO's request. In addition, no labels or product information could be produced. At the conclusion of the inspection, however, the CSO discovered and retrieved discarded Genesis II products and nutritional information panels from the firm's trash receptacle.
In addition to the FDA performing analyses of consumers' samples, a grand jury subpoena was served on Cloverhill in June 1994 for records relating to sales of bakery items they made to Genesis II. In an interview, representatives of Cloverhill told FDA investigators that no formal business arrangement had been made at any time to sell products to Genesis II. Patterson or his company's drivers simply showed up as "walk-ins" and purchased secondhand pastry items--those that were day-old, overweight, or had color or cosmetic defects--and repackaged them as low-calorie products. In addition, representatives told the FDA that Cloverhill did not make or sell a low-fat, low-calorie pastry product, nor had they ever used soy oil in production.
After additional subpoenas were served, the FDA learned that Genesis II had deceived more than 900 customers in 41 states. The agency also discovered that Genesis II used United Parcel Service to ship all its products to customers in other states, adding mail fraud to Patterson's other charges.
In addition, the FDA's Genesis II laboratory samples received from consumers all contained substantially higher fat and calorie contents than were listed on the labels. But even this finding failed to deter Patterson. In fact, it only seemed to egg him on.
Genesis II's records contained evidence that Patterson was in the process of preparing letters to his customers about a change in the manufacturer's baking process. The letter said that 4 grams of fat would now be added to Genesis II products. Another letter invited customers to contact the named laboratory to verify an attached analysis of the "Skinny Roll" for authenticity. FDA officials discovered on further investigation that the attached lab analysis was one that Cloverhill had performed on a different product--a newly developed low-fat cinnamon roll that the company was only considering marketing, but that wasn't yet available. Further, Genesis II letterhead had been superimposed on the top of the analysis, and the named laboratory's logo had been moved down. There was no mention of Cloverhill in the correspondence.
Patterson took the scam to even greater heights when he lied to FDA officials about his relationship with Cloverhill. He claimed that the manufacturer's owner had provided him with the fat and calorie information he put on his labeling. He also stated that the owner told him it was acceptable to have a "20 percent margin of error."
Once the laboratory's records verified that no analysis ever had been done in the name of Patterson or Genesis II, police arrested Patterson on criminal charges. Following his guilty plea, Patterson reported to the Federal Corrections Institution in Oxford, Wis., on March 19, 2001, to serve his term.
Table of Contents
| How to Subscribe |
Back Issues | Editorial Questions
FDA/Office of Public Affairs
Web page created by clb 2001-JUN-19.