Answers 02/06/1992
T92-7 Brad Stone
Feb. 6, 1992 (301) 443-3285
FDA URGES BUYERS CLUBS TO END SALES OF UNDERGROUND DDC
On Feb. 5, 1992, FDA informed AIDS buyers clubs throughout the United
States that FDA-sponsored laboratory analysis of samples of unauthorized, or
underground, versions of dideoxycytidine (DDC) -- an experimental AIDS
treatment -- showed potentially serious variations in product potency and
quality. The agency has determined that these results indicate that
underground DDC is produced under poor manufacturing conditions and that the
overall safety and purity of underground DDC is suspect. As a result, FDA
has strongly urged buyers clubs to cease the sale or distribution of
underground DDC and to notify their clientele of FDA's findings.
The term "buyers club" is loosely used to describe groups which
facilitate patient access to drugs and other products purportedly useful in
treating AIDS and related diseases.
In January 1992, the agency received reports that the amounts of DDC
contained in some capsules of the underground product were far higher or
lower than labelled. In response to these reports, FDA undertook to do its
own analysis of the product, collected samples from various buyers clubs and
had its laboratory analyze these samples.
-MORE-
Page 2, T92-7, DDC
FDA's analysis confirmed wide variations among the individual samples of
tested underground DDC. Some individual capsules were shown to contain no
DDC at all, while others contained more than twice the labelled amount.
Variations from labelled dosage levels were also found when the individual
units from each buyers club were combined into a composite sample for each
site; one composite contained only half the expected content.
FDA is concerned about these results because a significant variation
from recommended dosage levels of DDC could put patients at risk of injury,
particularly if the levels were too high. Excessive levels of DDC are known
to cause nerve damage in the hands and feet. Although the excess potency
found in FDA's analysis of the sampled underground DDC was short of the
levels certain to produce these conditions, it nevertheless could increase
patient risk of experiencing some serious adverse reactions.
Moreover, FDA believes that the significant inconsistency found in these
samples reflects lapses in manufacturing practices that could be associated
with increased risk of product contamination or other problems. At a
minimum, these findings demonstrate that it is not possible to assure the
quality or safety of these products.
In view of these concerns, FDA has notified buyers clubs that
underground DDC poses an unacceptable risk to public health, that sales and
distribution of the product should cease immediately and that they should
inform their clientele about the potential problems associated with these
products. FDA will work in cooperation with buyers clubs in this effort and
will take other appropriate steps to protect the public health.
-MORE-
Page 3, T92-7, DDC
Unlike underground DDC, the authorized version of DDC is manufactured
under strictly regulated conditions that ensure consistent product quality.
Nevertheless, it is an experimental drug whose safety and efficacy are still
under evaluation by FDA. The agency is currently reviewing, on an expedited
basis, a new drug application for DDC submitted in October 1991 by the
drug's authorized manufacturer, Hoffmann-La Roche of Nutley, N.J.
In the meantime, more than 3,500 patients are enrolled in FDA-sanctioned
clinical trials of the drug being conducted by the National Cancer
Institute, the National Institutes of Health and Hoffmann-La Roche. In
addition, DDC is being made available to more than 6,000 patients with AIDS
and advanced AIDS-related complex who fail to benefit from or are unable to
tolerate treatment with the approved AIDS treatment, zidovudine, commonly
called AZT.